daily Menu
Weekdays: 9a - 9p
Weekends: 3p - 9p
No Reservations • First Come, First Served
Breakfast Served 9AM - 3PM
Most Popular
$16
ROCKET PLATTER** (v)
One pancake, two farm eggs, two strips of bacon, hashbrowns
$16
Egg-tastic
$12
EGGS ANY WAY YOU LIKE** (v) (gf)
Two farm eggs, with side of hashbrowns, & choice of toast
$12
add protein - price varies
$15
DENVER OMELETTE** (gf)
Three farm egg omelette with bell pepper, ham, onion, cheddar, with side of hashbrowns, & choice of toast
$15
$13
TOFU SCRAMBLE (v) (gf)
Scramble of tofu, veggie sausage, bell pepper, artichoke hearts marinated in chili flakes, spinach, with side of hashbrowns, & choice of toast
$13
Sandwiches & Burritos
$15
COMMUTER SANDWICH** (v) (gf)
Two scrambled farm eggs, cheddar cheese, on a croissant, with side of hashbrowns
$15
add protein - price varies
$15
BREAKFAST BURRITO** (v) (gf)*
Scrambled farm eggs, cheddar cheese, peppers, french fries, pinto beans, wrapped in a flour tortilla, topped with ranchero sauce, cilantro crema, & pico de gallo | 15
$15
add protein - price varies
*gf = no tortilla
$17
THE STENDLER** (gf)*
Slow-cooked corned beef, scrambled farm eggs, hashbrowns, cheddar cheese, wrapped in a flour tortilla, topped with Sriracha
$17
*gf = no tortilla
Lighter Bites
One $7 • Two $12
CLASSIC PANCAKES (v)
Served with butter & maple syrup
One $7 • Two $12
add: bacon • chocolate chips • blueberries • strawberries +2 per cake
$14
FRUIT FETISH (gf)
Honeypie Bakeshop Honey-Nut Granola, yogurt, fresh berries, topped with Wisconsin honey
$14
$5
FROM-SCRATCH BISCUIT & JAM
House-made biscuit. Served with butter & house-made jam
$5
$6
EVERYTHING BAGEL
Toasted, served with whipped herb cream cheese
$6
Sides
$3
Toast
Sourdough • Rye
$3
Biscuit +2
Gluten Free +2
$1
House-Made Jam (v) (gf)
$1
$4
Hashbrowns (v) (gf)
$4
$3
Single Egg any way (v) (gf)
$3
egg whites only +2
$4
Tofu Scramble (v) (gf)
$4
$2
Bacon (gf)
$2
$4
Ham • Corned Beef (gf)
$4
$4
Sausage • Vegan Sausage (gf)
$4
$5
Pork Belly (gf)
$5
$5
Fruit Cup (v) (gf)
$5
Dips
$13
SPINACH ARTICHOKE
Artichokes, spinach, parmesan, cream cheese. Served with crostinis
$13
$10
HUMMUS (v)
House-made hummus, crispy chickpeas, pickled veggies, tapenade. Served with toasted pita
$10
$10
VEGAN BUFFALO CAULIFLOWER DIP (v)
House-made buffalo cauliflower dip, topped with crumbled vegan cheese, chives. Served with fried flatbread
$10
Various Forms of Potatoes
$17
COMET POUTINE
We couldn’t call ourselves a Wisconsin joint if we didn’t include POUTINE. French fries, pork belly, Wisconsin cheese curds, beer gravy, scallions
$17
$6
PLATE OF FRIES (v) (gf)
Classic fries served with chipotle mayo
$6
sub: spicy fries with cucumber dill +1
$16
VEGAN CHILI CHEESE FRIES (v)
French fries topped with Comet’s veggie chili, "cheese" sauce, green onion
$16
$4
MASHED POTATOES & GRAVY (v) (gf)
Mixed with bacon, chives, sour cream, topped with house-made beer gravy
$4
$9
CHEESY POTATOES (gf)
Chive mashed potatoes, cheese curds, cheddar cheese, broiled, topped with green onion
$9
Soups
Cup $5 • Bowl $8
TOMATO SOUP (v) (gf)
House-made topped with chives
Cup $5 • Bowl $8
Cup $5 • Bowl $8
VEGGIE CHILI (v) (gf)
Comet’s signature blend of peppers and spices, with choice of toppings: cheese, onion, noodles, sour cream
Cup $5 • Bowl $8
Fresh-Tossed Salads
add: grilled or fried chicken +4 • tofu +3
tomato tossed in cilantro crema, topped with pepitas & cojita cheese
SEASONAL SALAD (v) (gf)
Hundred Acre spring mix, arugula, roasted corn, onion, poblano, cilantro, cherry
tomato tossed in cilantro crema, topped with pepitas & cojita cheese
$15
$15
$15
CAESAR SALAD (v) (gf)
Romaine lettuce, house-made croutons, pepperoncini, Parmesan, tossed with Caesar dressing
$15
Small $7 • Large $12
HOUSE SALAD (v) (gf)
Hundred Acre greens, shaved carrots, cherry tomato, cucumber with choice of house-made dressing served on the side
Small $7 • Large $12
Ranch • Cilantro Crema • 1000 Island • Balsamic Vin • Truffle Vin • Caesar • Ginger
SANDWICHES
$18
BIG LUCK BURGER** (v)* (gf)
Two smashed beef patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, house-made pickles, 1000 Island, on a sesame seed bun
$18
add bacon +2 • egg +3
*V: house-made vegan patty contains lentils & walnuts
$17
FRIED CHICKEN SAMMIE
Hand-breaded fried chicken, house pickles, mayo, lettuce, tomato, on a sesame seed bun
$17
make it a Buffalo Chicken Sammie +1
$17
COMET CLUB (gf)
Turkey, ham, bacon, cheddar, pickled red onion, lettuce, tomato, cilantro crema, on toasted sourdough
$17
$16
THE LEGHORN (gf)
Pulled chicken, house-made apricot jam, herbed cream cheese, iceberg lettuce, cucumbers, pickled red onion, on toasted sourdough
$16
$16
REUBEN (v) (gf)
Slow-cooked corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, 1000 Island, grilled on salted rye
$16
$16
B.E.L.T.** (v) (gf)
Sunny farm egg, pork belly, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo, on a sesame seed bun, with side of hashbrowns
$16
$17
PATTY DIJONNAISE (v)* (gf)
Two smashed beef patties, American cheese, house-made pickles, beer onions, dijonnaise, on salted rye
$17
*V: house-made vegan patty contains lentils & walnuts
$16
JAKE THE STEAK (v) (gf)
Roast beef, roasted garlic miso mayo, balsamic caramelized onion, arugula, roasted mushrooms, provolone cheese, broiled on a hoagie
$16
$14
THE CHEESY TOMATO (v) (gf)
Provolone & mozzarella, tomatoes, lettuce, red onion, mayo, herbs, broiled on a hoagie
$14
Make it a... BUTTAFUCCO (v) (gf) (adds hot giardiniera peppers) +1
add roast beef or seitan +4
$16
ARTICHOKE MELT (v) (gf)
Artichoke hearts marinated in chili flakes, provolone, red onion, spinach, mayo, herbs, broiled on hoagie bun
$16
$16
VEGAN SHAWARMA (v) (gf)
Marinated oyster mushrooms, tapenade, lettuce, marinated tomato, cucumber dill sauce, on a warm pita
$16
$17
CHOPPED CHEESE & BEEF** (v) (gf)
Roast beef, bell peppers, mushrooms, provolone, American cheese, chipotle mayo, on a hoagie bun
$17
$15
GRILLED CHEESE + TOMATO SOUP (v) (gf)
Provolone, mozzarella & American cheeses on sourdough, with a cup of house-made tomato soup & fries
$15
add: bacon +2
Famous Dishes
As featured on Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives!
$19
THE CLASSIC MEATLOAF
Beef-pork meatloaf, bacon-chive mashed potatoes, grilled tomatoes, bacon, onions, open face on salted rye topped with beer gravy & chives
$19
$17
COMPACT TURKEY DINNER
Slow-roasted turkey, sage stuffing, & chive mashed potatoes that’s beer-battered, fried, & topped with country gravy. Served with Vegetable of the Day
$17
Other Mains
$16
MAC & CHEESE (v)
Classic creamy mac & cheese, covered with even MORE cheese, broiled, & topped with green onion
$16
add: chili +2 • bacon +2 • ham +4 • housemade seitan +4
$16
VEGAN SALISBURY STEAK (v)
Two house-made vegan lentil walnut patties over chive mashed potatoes, topped with sautéed mushrooms, Brussels sprouts, & covered with beer gravy
$16
$16
CHICKEN A LA COMET
House-made biscuit topped with pulled chicken, white gravy, mushrooms, red & poblano peppers
$16
$16
CHICKEN STRIPS
Hand-breaded fried chicken tenders, choice of BBQ or Buffalo dipping sauce, with side of fries & ranch
$16
$16
VEGAN WINGS (v)
House-made seitan, battered & fried, tossed in choice of BBQ or Buffalo sauce, with side of fries & ranch
$16
$18
FRIDAY FISH FRY (V)
Beer-battered fish served with French fries, fresh slaw, lemon, house-made tartar sauce, rye toast
$18
SERVED FRIDAYS ONLY!
DESSERTS
Pie $9 • Treats vary
FRESH PIE & TREATS
All of our goodies are made-from-scratch and delivered daily from our sister bakery, Honeypie Bakeshop, in Bay View, MKE.
Pie $9 • Treats vary
(v) = vegan OPTIONAL | (gf) = gluten friendly OPTIONAL (prepared alongside gluten items)
**Consuming raw or undercooked meat or egg may increase the chance of food borne illness.